Kelly+Mullen+Module

In debate, there is usually a question that is posed for debaters to answer. It is stated in the form of a resolution. So is the following question in which you may take either the affirmative or the negative position."Resolved, directing is a more important art and craft than acting."

Both acting and directing are important aspects to the overall performance. However, a play can occur without a director, but does not exist without actors. Therefore, acting is a more important act and craft than directing.

The director’s job consists of giving “a production a clear stylistic point of view that integrates all the elements of the performance...” (1). This is important because theatre needs a leader to make these types of decisions so that the production does not turn into chaos (2). However, if the actors cannot accurately portray the director’s vision to the audience, then it is not received and is ultimately lost. This presents the actor with a more challenging role because he or she has to personally channel the character through the director’s point of view as well as their own. The actor has to research the role and analyze it either externally or internally or both for themselves while also playing it towards what the director has in mind. The performance is mostly based on the acting. Costumes, set designs, and lighting etc., are all extras surrounding the actors. Actors can portray a set through actions such as holding a light which suggests it’s night or the different actions that change the meaning of a table (2). Actions can create a certain setting or mood which determines the whole meaning behind the play.

Directing is essential to the success of a production, but not as essential as the acting.

Word Count: 244


 * 1) Arnold. //Creative Spirit//.
 * 2) Richmond Lecture.